Finders Fee
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2addd/2adddc205124061689501cd7f0c1b7c79a3cfccf" alt=""
After the police arrived, it was all a blur. Joe received a call shortly after the matter was settled from the lawyers representing the original owner. They told him he could keep $600,000.00 as a reward, and that the rest should be returned. It’s not fair but his options were very limited. What if it is not true?